Music upload – Project X (Amiga)

I have to say that I’ve always had something of a love-hate relationship with Project X. Of course, I’m talking about the side-scrolling spaceship shooter developed and published by Team17 for the Amiga in 1992, and not the completely unrelated 2012 teen comedy film!

I adore the visuals, presentation, and music of Project X. The sprites are colourful and beautifully animated, the hostile aliens are varied in appearance and sometimes wonderfully exotic, and some of the scrolling sci-fi backdrops are just gorgeous. The sound effects are nice and meaty, and the digitised speech gives the game a real arcade quality. Team17 certainly managed to squeeze a lot out of the OCS hardware.

And, of course, there are two awesome title screen tracks from Amiga music maestro Allister Brimble — the pumping, thumping, dance melodies of “rave mode” and the fabulously chilled-out panpipes and flute sounds of “old-timer mode”, also known as Thesmophoria.

In an interview with Gracious Films (part of the bonus content from their Amiga Years film), Brimble confesses that he was asked to write a dance-style track for Project X despite having no experience of the genre and having never been to a nightclub. He had to get a friend to send him some examples of “modern rave music” to help him compose the track. Well, I think he did a fantastic job of nailing the early 90s rave vibe.

However, I’m not a huge fan of Project X’s gameplay. It’s frustratingly hard and unfair and a poor imitation of its arcade influences, such as the likes of R-Type and Salamander.

Many of the enemies are bullet sponges and the waves often come too thick and fast for you to react to and dispatch.

Even with the better weapons, I seem to spend more time dodging the aliens than shooting the bastards. And from level 2 onwards you also have to contend with surface collisions, water sections that dramatically slow your ship down, and environmental hazards such as storms, rockfalls, and lava eruptions.

And you lose most of your upgrades upon dying, which feels unnecessarily punitive and puts you at a massive disadvantage during tough wave sequences and boss fights. Sometimes it’s simply better to restart than carry on after losing a life. The boss fights, by the way, are very tedious, uninspired and anticlimactic.

Paradoxically, despite the fast action, the pace is strangely plodding. The levels just drag on and don’t throw up enough variety — they feel very stretched out and repetitive. I mean, how many times do we need to go through that bloody asteroid field on level 1? It doesn’t add any value.

And while it’s nice that Team17 put in multiple ways to select weapons upgrades, waggling your stick from left to right shouldn’t have been one of them. It’s far too easy to do unintentionally, especially in a game where you’re constantly moving your ship back and forth.

Project X is certainly a game that would have benefited from more thorough playtesting. However, Team17 did follow it up with a “special edition” in 1993, in which they recognised and addressed some of the issues.

They retuned the difficulty somewhat, largely by significantly shortening some of the levels and letting the player keep more of their upgrades after losing a ship. You also start with a few power-ups to help you through the early waves.

But, I’ve still never got past level 2 in either version without the use of cheats. Also, they never fixed the accidental weapon select problem, but at least there’s now a WHDLoad hack to prevent that from happening.

And these SE tweaks don’t disguise the fact that Project X is an average shooter at best. The level designs lack imagination and the action fails to reward or engage in the same way as the classic shumps of the period, such as the far superior Thunder Force games on the Sega Mega Drive.

I also find it slightly bizarre that Project X gives you a choice of two tunes to listen to on the menu screen but no music plays in-game except for an unrelated track during the boss fights. Presumably, this was because of memory or sound channel constraints?

The Thesmophoria track was removed from the SE version, which is a shame because it’s a great piece of music.

Still, the visuals and Allister Brimble’s soundtrack keep bringing me back to play this game. I listen to the music, play for 5-10 minutes, and then ungraciously rage quit. As I said, it’s a love-hate relationship.

If you’re a fan of Allister Brimble, you should definitely check out his 2013 album The Amiga Works, which features remakes, using modern samples and equipment, of his best tracks from the Amiga era, including both tunes from Project X. The Alien Breed tracks are especially good. You can buy the album at http://www.amigaworks.com.

You can checkout my classic video game music playlist on YouTube.

4 thoughts on “Music upload – Project X (Amiga)

  1. The music was definitely better than the game. It seems unkind, but I think that was the case with several Team 17 games! They made technically impressive stuff, that somehow felt cold and soulless to play. But I bought most of them, with a favourite being Superfrog. Thanks for reminding me about the brilliant title track for PX. My favourite Amiga track of all time would have to be ‘Second Floor’ from the Turrican 3 soundtrack.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Yeah, I totally agree. I personally feel that like the Bitmap Brothers, Team 17 were a bit overrated as a game developer. They both put out good some technically good looking and sounding games but much of their output was mediocre with too much of a focus on style over substance.

      Plus Team 17 had very few original ideas. Alien Breed was a gauntlet-like that borrowed heavily from Into the Eagle’s Nest and Alien Syndrome, Alien Breed 3D was a poor Doom clone, Body Blows was an uninspired Street Fighter II rip off, Assasin was an unashamed Strider clone, Super Frog a Sonic/Mario wannabe, Project X was basically just R-type, and Worms was a more polished and quirky version of Scorched Earth.

      That said, I do like Worms and still play it today, and I definitely have a soft spot for the 2D Alien Breed games and Super Frog. And Team 17 games always had great music thanks to Alister Brimble.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Absolutely agree, on all fronts, and Allister Brimble’s music inspired me to get into Octamed. I was never that good, but got a track reviewed in a magazine – though I can’t remember which! I could kick myself for selling my 1200 and losing all my disks along the way. I found your website via an old Guardian piece about the Amiga; you had commented underneath with a link to your blog. And I arrived at the Guardian article because I decided it might be nice to see if trackers still exist (and they do! SunVox, Renoise) and whether it might be fun to get back into all that, some 28 years after the last time! Anyway, I will cut my life story short here! Thanks for the blog and the inspiration.

        Liked by 1 person

        1. Nice one on getting your music into a magazine. I remember getting a free version of Octamed on the cover of Amiga Format but I only really spent a few hours playing with it before getting bored!

          I also hugely regret selling my upgraded A1200 and along with hundreds of disks and games, including 20-30 boxed originals. Still, at least I can play my favourites easily enough through WinUAE and Amibian.

          Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s